next up previous
Next: Choice of gene Up: Trees from molecules Previous: Example: globin genes

Gene trees vs. species trees

Note that the tree drawn from the -globin amino acid sequences corresponds with our intuition (and good external evidence) about the evolutionary relationships among the taxa that donated those sequences. It is by no means always the case that ``gene trees" and ``species trees" have such a nice correspondence(Takahata[12]) (though that is often the unspoken hope of molecular systematists). As an example of how gene and species trees can fail to agree, consider the following situation:

The common ancestor (O) of three species A, B, and C was polymorphic for the gene being studied, with three alleles y, x, and , where x and are very similar, and y different from both. The tree which we are able to infer from present-day data on this gene may be quite misleading, depending on which of O's alleles were passed on to its descendants. This is likely to be a problem if one tries to use slowly-evolving molecules with recently-diverged species, as in the tree abovegif. This leads us to the problem of choosing genes.



Simon Cawley
Tue May 12 11:50:21 PDT 1998